Journal of Avian Biology

Developing in suboptimal temperatures can have widespread negative effects in organisms, but early exposure to thermal challenges can also trigger increased investment in thermoregulatory capacity. Within birds, the effects of cold exposure during incubation may differ between precocial and altricial species due to differences in the ontogeny of thermoregulation. To date, most of the evidence showing that embryonic cold exposure shapes future thermoregulatory capacity comes from a few precocial species in laboratory settings. Less is known about sensitivity to low-temperature incubation in altricial species which only become fully endothermic after hatching. In this study, we tested the effects of cold temperatures during embryonic development by temporarily cooling the nest boxes of free-living tree swallows (Tachycineta bicolor) during late incubation and subsequently exposing nestlings to an acute cold challenge. Cold exposure during early development made nestlings better at maintaining their body temperatures during the acute challenge. Developmentally cold-exposed birds also had higher thyroxine (T4) levels when sampled at lower ambient temperatures, whereas control birds showed the opposite relationship. Among nestlings that failed to maintain their body temperature during the acute cold challenge, developmentally cold-exposed nestlings secreted more corticosterone during the acute cold challenge than control nestlings. Despite these changes, cold-exposed birds did not differ from controls in cold-induced metabolic rates, body mass, or bacteria killing ability. These results are, to our knowledge, the first to show that developmental cold exposure increases the capacity to maintain body temperature during future cold challenges in a songbird. These findings suggest that experiencing even a mild decline in ambient temperatures during embryonic development could prime birds to cope more effectively with harsh or variable environmental conditions later in life.

Urbanisation imposes novel environmental conditions that can shape phenotypic traits including plumage, yet, its effects on characteristics beyond colouration remain poorly understood. Feather microstructure plays an important role in thermoregulation, protection from solar radiation and waterproofing, and its expression is sensitive to environmental conditions. Here, we quantified feather barbule density, a key component of feather microstructure, in great tits (Parus major) from five urban-rural paired populations across Europe to assess its association with urbanisation, temperature and elevation. We found no significant effects of the urban environment or temperature. However, feather microstructure significantly varied between the studied areas and was positively associated with elevation and ultraviolet B (UV-B) radiation, suggesting a potential adaptive response to variation in solar radiation.

1. Organisms rely on environmental cues, such as moonlight illumination and weather, to modulate nocturnal behaviors that reduce predation risk and conserve energy during demanding periods. Urbanization can alter the reliability of cues, potentially impairing organisms' ability to respond appropriately with consequences in increasingly urbanized landscapes. 2. We leveraged the Motus Wildlife Tracking System to identify roost initiation, roost departure and nocturnal restlessness of dark-eyed juncos (Junco hyemalis) overwintering along an urban to rural gradient to determine if activity patterns are affected by weather, moonlight illumination, and urbanization. 3. Nocturnal behavior of overwintering juncos varied with environmental factors, including moonlight illumination and temperature. However, the strength of these responses differed among sites, suggesting that natural cues of moonlight illumination were masked in urban areas, where individuals were more responsive to temperature. 4. Our results suggest that urbanization weakens birds' responsiveness to natural light cues, likely because artificial lighting reduces the visibility of moonlight; representing a key mechanism by which human-altered landscapes can disrupt nocturnal ecology in birds.

Reliable morphological criteria for sexing birds without the need for invasive procedures are scientifically and ethically valuable. Smith et al (2005) reported that iris colour assigns the genetic sex of Starlings Sturnus vulgaris with 98% accuracy, and bill base colour with 100% accuracy when birds are in breeding condition, but these figures have not been tested independently. We applied their criteria to 31 captive Starlings in breeding condition, using three observers blind to genetic sex, two of them new to Starling sexing. Bill base colour correctly predicted genetic sex for all 29 birds scored, with complete observer agreement. Mean iris score was correct for 27 of 31 (87.1%), fewer than the 94 of 96 reported by Smith et al (2005) for birds in breeding condition (Fisher exact test, P = 0.031), although with so few errors in either study this comparison is imprecise. Observer agreement was high, so these errors reflect iris colouration conflicting with genetic sex rather than inconsistent scoring; bill base colour was correct for all four misassigned birds. Body mass and tarsus length classified 77% and 58% of birds correctly, their published thresholds missing in opposite directions. We conclude that bill base colour should be the primary criterion for sexing Starlings in breeding condition; the accuracy of iris colour should not be assumed to be 98%.

Vertebrates cope with rapid temperature fluctuations by plastically adjusting their behaviour and physiology. This phenotypic plasticity is partly mediated by plastic changes in glucocorticoid levels; however, whether individual differences in endocrine plasticity are associated with fitness remains unknown. Here, we examined the relationship between individual variation in glucocorticoid plasticity in response to air temperature changes and reproductive success in a wild great tit population (Parus major). Over nine years, we collected repeated measurements of baseline and stress-induced corticosterone during nestling rearing. We found consistent reaction norm patterns in hormone response to temperature variation -- as shown in a previous study conducted over a shorter period. This provides robust evidence of individual differences in average hormone levels (intercepts) and the strength of the plastic response (slopes), indicating potential for evolution. However, neither intercepts nor slopes were associated with reproductive success (fledgling number or brood mass), suggesting that individual variation in endocrine plasticity was not under natural selection, at least within the environmental conditions experienced. This study provides a first empirical test of the evolutionary implications of endocrine plasticity in the wild and highlights the need to assess its fitness relevance under more extreme conditions, such as those expected under future climate scenarios.

Fledglings of burrow-nesting seabirds are vulnerable to disorientation by artificial light at night (ALAN) and grounding in coastal human settlements, where most individuals presumably perish if not rescued. Accurate estimates of the effects of stranding on seabird populations remain elusive due to several levels of uncertainty, such as the number of stranded seabirds estimated to remain undiscovered by rescuers. One species subjected to stranding is the Atlantic puffin (Fratercula arctica). We hypothesized that the detection probability of puffin fledglings by the Puffin Patrol rescue program, operating in Newfoundland, Canada, is affected by light level, concealment level, and search effort. We deployed realistic puffin decoys in locations of varying light and concealment levels throughout two sites that are searched nightly by rescuers and measured the amount of time and search effort required until each decoy was found. Approximately 78% more search effort was required to find a decoy in darkness (32.0 min) compared with illuminated conditions (18.0 min), and up to 100% more search effort was required to find a decoy placed in concealed conditions (35.5 min) than one in the open (17.5 min). After two hours of searching, on average over 10% of decoys were still not found, although each additional minute of search effort increased detection rate of an individual decoy by 0.6%. In combination with recent advances in our knowledge of seabird post-stranding behaviour, our study offers a first step in the development of correction factors which can be adapted to site- and species-specific requirements of other rescue programs around the world that rely on volunteers to search for stranded birds. Application of such correction factors will hopefully result in better estimation of mortality rates and their resultant effects on populations.

Artificial light at night (ALAN) disrupts the natural light-dark cycle, which is the most important cue for synchronizing circadian clocks. If populations most exposed to ALAN adapt to get less disturbed by it, we expect forest and city populations to differ genetically. We tested this prediction in a common garden experiment using a songbird, the great tit (Parus major), originating from forest and city populations. We simulated ALAN exposure during the breeding season by keeping the birds in pairs under ALAN or dark nights for three months and then repeated the experiment in the following year with the same pairs under the opposite treatment. The advancement of daily onset under ALAN disappeared over time for city birds, but not for their forest counterparts. For these same birds, we measured their onset of daily activity under constant dim light and shift in activity in response to light pulses and showed that the city/forest difference in behavioural response was not reflected in any clock property measured. This indicates that city and forest birds differ genetically in the downstream behavioural response to ALAN, and not in the circadian clock. Thus, urbanization is unlikely to select for divergence in circadian clock properties in songbirds.

Diurnal ectotherms in hot and dry ecosystems face an acquisition trade-off between maximizing collective energy intake and minimizing individual exposure time. We employed optimal foraging and thermoregulation models to examine the surface foraging and thermoregulatory strategies of Pogonomyrmex barbatus foragers in response to habitat warming in a tropical deciduous forest. Foraging activity was evaluated using field-based thermal performance curves (fTPCs) for individual foraging speed and collective foraging success. Thermoregulation was assessed through indices of thermal unsuitability, as well as thermoregulatory effectiveness and exploitation. Our results show that afternoon conditions were significantly hotter and drier than those in the morning. Furthermore, the decoupling of fTPCs was dynamic; while the optimal temperature (Topt) for individual foraging speed remained stable at 44 degrees C, the Topt for collective foraging success shifted from 35 degrees C in the morning to 41 degrees C in the afternoon. This shift in foraging strategy, driven by stressful afternoon conditions, was reflected in a transition of the thermoregulatory strategy. Specifically, the probability of foraging activity decreased as thermal unsuitability increased, with a lower baseline in the afternoon. The thermoregulatory exploitation dropped from 94% in the morning to 63% in the afternoon. Based on thermoregulatory effectiveness, foragers transitioned from an active thermoregulatory strategy in the morning to a thermoconformist strategy in the afternoon while foraging on the surface. So, the observed colonies optimized the balance between individual foraging speed and collective foraging success through a thermoregulatory strategy that was primarily spatial in the morning and strictly temporal in the afternoon. A comparison with historical data from the same site reveals a 40% contraction in the total daily foraging window since 2013.

Exotic species can reshape native communities, in the extreme, to local extirpation. Before that, natives may adjust where and when they use the landscape, in ways that allow coexistence and may be the earliest sign of trouble. Distinguishing coexistence built on such adjustment from one built on pre-existing niche differences requires comparing a native where the invader is absent with the same native where it is present, across sites at different invasion stages. Using eight years (2018-2026) of camera-trap data from 103 stations across Uruguay (154,590 camera-nights), we asked how the invasive axis deer (Axis axis) affects the space and time use of two native cervids: the forest-dwelling brown brocket (Subulo gouazoubira) and the grassland-restricted pampas deer (Ozotoceros bezoarticus). Activity-overlap, directional-avoidance, hierarchical activity, and two-species occupancy analyses showed sharply divergent dyads. A. axis and S. gouazoubira shared forest yet segregated in space and along the understory stratum the brocket requires and the invader avoids, and shifted their diel activity by context; understory cover fell with A. axis abundance, consistent with habitat modification. For A. axis and O. bezoarticus, segregation was intrinsic, opposite diel niches and habitats, with no support for a detectable shift in pampas deer behavior. The only behavioral signal was asymmetric: the invader, rather than the native, appeared to adjust, though few shared sites warrant caution. The same invader thus drives different mechanisms, but coexistence is provisional: A. axis is still expanding, far from equilibrium, so these shifts read best as early warning signals.

Researcher disturbance can alter the behavior, survival, and breeding success of wildlife, with effects that are especially well-documented in waterbirds. Anecdotal reports suggest that disturbance can even cause cavity-nesting species to alter the structure of their nests. We used a long-term study of a burrowing seabird, the Leach's Storm-Petrel (Hydrobates leucorhous), to ask whether storm-petrels renovate existing burrows and whether such renovation is related to a history of researcher disturbance. Our study was conducted at the Bowdoin Scientific Station on Kent Island, New Brunswick, Canada, where in 2024 we measured the burrow architecture of 363 burrows, including length and structure for occupied and unoccupied burrows both inside and outside a long-term study site with consistent research activity. Of these, 150 burrows had been measured in 2006, allowing for direct longitudinal comparison of burrow architecture. Nearly all burrows changed in length over the 18-year study period (mean absolute change = 20.8 cm +- 18.2 SD). A linear model revealed two contrasting processes of burrow length change: more frequently occupied burrows grew longer, whereas initially longer burrows shortened towards mean burrow length (~50 cm) through collapse. Occupied burrows inside the long-term study site were on average 34% longer and significantly more complex than burrows adjacent to the site, suggesting that researcher disturbance directly or indirectly reshapes burrows. Overall, these results show that storm-petrel burrows are shaped by cycles of renovation and subsequent collapse that may be exacerbated by human disturbance. Given ongoing population declines in storm-petrels and other cavity-nesting seabirds, this study emphasizes the need to balance scientific research with minimizing disturbance, particularly in long-term studies.

Immune defenses may vary across environments due to differences in life history or abiotic and biotic characteristics, but few studies have compared the strength of immune responses across broad geographical gradients. Here we investigated how bacteria killing ability (BKA), a measure of constitutive innate immune function, varies among populations of tree swallows (Tachycineta bicolor) inhabiting different environments. We hypothesized that populations living in unpredictable environments, which also have shorter breeding seasons and thus fewer opportunities to renest in the event of reproductive failure, would invest in reproduction at the expense of immunity. To test this hypothesis, we measured BKA and monitored reproductive activity in four populations located across most of the breeding range of tree swallows, in Tennessee, New York, Wyoming and Alaska. Consistent with our predictions, BKA was lowest in Alaska and Wyoming and highest in Tennessee. In most populations BKA was also lower during incubation than during nestling provisioning, and lower in males than in females. These results suggest that the high reproductive investment seen in populations experiencing more unpredictable breeding conditions may come at a cost to immune function. While reduced immune investment could increase susceptibility to parasites, this potential cost is likely offset by lower parasite pressure in these environments, limiting the need for maintaining strong constitutive innate defenses like BKA.

Multifunctional anatomical structures must accommodate potentially competing performance demands, leading to functional tradeoffs. The mammal rostrum (snout) is involved in multiple functions, including feeding, respiratory conditioning, olfaction, and, in most bats, echolocation. Therefore, it serves as an ideal system to investigate whether and how functional tradeoffs promote or constrain morphological diversification. While the external morphology of the rostrum has been linked with mechanical demands of feeding in bats, the factors and processes influencing its internal morphology, including the turbinals in the nasal cavity, remain comparatively unexplored. Here we investigate how internal rostral morphology reflects specialization and tradeoffs among respiratory air conditioning, echolocation, and olfaction by quantifying turbinal morphological diversity in a phylogenetically and ecologically diverse sample of bat species. We find that echolocation mode predominantly influences both the ethmoturbinal complex (ETc) and maxilloturbinal (MT) systems, with nasal-emitting bats having reduced and less complex turbinals compared to oral and non-laryngeally echolocating bat species. MT complexity and surface area are not associated with bioclimatic variables representing thermal variability and aridity. However, the ETc exhibits higher complexity in plantivorous bats than faunivorous bats, suggesting higher olfactory reliance. While MT morphological disparity was predominantly explained by echolocation mode, ETc morphological disparity was associated with both echolocation mode and diet, suggesting potentially opposing demands favoring turbinal reduction for sound transmission and elaboration for olfaction. Among nasal emitters, which must accommodate both demands within the nasal cavity, ETc complexity exhibited higher relative disparity compared to MT complexity. These patterns suggest that competing functional demands may promote or maintain morphological diversity, possibly through ecological specialization and/or many-to-one mapping between morphology and performance.

1. Adaptive behavioural strategies require animals to simultaneously navigate social and ecological domains across multiple spatial and temporal scales. Although drones and computer vision have recently transformed the study of wild animal societies, many nocturnal species and those occupying structurally complex habitats remain inaccessible to these approaches, limiting our understanding of behaviour in natural settings. 2. We aimed to determine how behavioural strategies are organised across nested spatial and temporal scales within a wild communication network. 3. We used three-dimensional acoustic localisation and source separation to track individual male Hyperolius sp. A, a nocturnal African reed frog, within a natural rainforest chorus and quantify patterns of site fidelity, movement, spatial organisation, and call-timing interactions. 4. Males exhibited significant site fidelity across nights, while chorus spatial structure varied with local caller density. Within nights, individuals followed a stereotyped behavioural sequence, descending from elevated arboreal refugia before settling into lower calling positions near breeding sites. At finer temporal scales, call-timing interactions varied according to both local competitor density and the proximity of neighbouring rivals. 5. These findings demonstrate that behavioural strategies emerge across nested spatial and temporal scales and that long-term spatial positioning, short-term movement decisions, and moment-to-moment signalling interactions are tightly linked within natural communication networks. More broadly, acoustic localisation provides a powerful framework for studying behaviour in species and habitats that remain difficult to observe using conventional approaches.

Colony defence is critical for the survival of wild honeybees but presents a challenge for local populations and beekeepers. Apis mellifera scutellata is an important pollinator in its native range, a large area of Southern and Eastern Africa 1, but is reputed for its explosive temperament. Here, we present data demonstrating that this behaviour is only exhibited by a small fraction of colonies, while others are relatively docile. This sheds new light on this subspecies and on its likely evolutionary trajectory. We further characterize the different elements of this defensive response and compare them to that of A. m. carnica and A. m. mellifera. We show that each subspecies invests differently in the two steps of the behavioural sequence (alert and attack). Furthermore, our results suggest that the task of attacking is carried out by specialized workers in carnica, but not in the other subspecies tested, highlighting subtle differences in colony organization across subspecies. Finally, we discovered that defenders from A. m. scutellata and scutellata-hybrid colonies can locate a target that was stung up to 2 h and 3 h earlier, respectively, whereas European bees could only do so for 30 min. This long-term marking could confer an advantage against returning predators with few weak points, such as honey badgers and humans wearing protective clothing. Overall, we offer a fresh perspective on this controversial but important subspecies of honeybees, with implications for both future studies and daily management.

Ground-nesting wild bees require suitable soil conditions for their below-ground development and overwintering life stages. Understanding how soil translocation and disturbance affect individuals and the following generations of bees is important for identifying conservation measures for ground-nesting wild bees. We investigated the effects of soil translocation and disturbance on the ground-nesting solitary spring mining bee Colletes cunicularius. In a replicated controlled design, we compared the effects of soil translocation with different degrees of disturbance on the number of surviving bees and the emergence time. We found that soil translocation and disturbance reduced bee survival but did not result in complete mortality, with some individuals surviving even under severe soil disturbance. There was no evidence that soil disturbance affected the timing of spring emergence, suggesting that disturbance is unlikely to alter the timing of nest construction and, consequently, the production of the next generation. Our results indicate that translocating soil containing overwintering bees could be a promising conservation measure to compensate for habitat loss caused by land conversion.

Fruit resource availability can influence the local abundance of avian frugivores through bottom-up regulation, but whether greater resource availability translates into higher visitation rates to fruiting trees remains poorly understood. Greater fruit availability could increase visitation by supporting larger frugivore populations, or reduce visitation to individual trees if increases in frugivore abundance are not proportionate to those in fruit availability or if frugivores distribute their foraging effort. Understanding these relationships can provide insights into the relative role of abundance and trait-based mechanisms in structuring plant-frugivore communities. We compared fruit availability, avian frugivore abundance, and frugivore visitation rates on fruiting trees across two protected wet tropical forest sites: Anamalai Tiger Reserve in the Western Ghats and Namdapha Tiger Reserve in the Eastern Himalaya. Specifically, we quantified the availability of bird-consumed fruits across one-ha patches, estimated local abundances of major frugivore groups, and tested whether visitation rates on individual fruiting trees were related to frugivore abundance, body mass, and degree of frugivory. We found that small-seeded fruit availability was significantly higher in Anamalai than in Namdapha. Local abundances of several relatively small-bodied frugivore groups, including bulbuls, barbets, fairy-bluebirds, and mynas, were also higher in Anamalai. However, visitation rates of several frugivore groups on individual fruiting trees were higher in Namdapha. Visitation rates across all avian frugivore species were associated with frugivore abundances only in Anamalai, and not associated with body mass or degree of frugivory in either site. Thus, although greater fruit availability was likely associated with higher frugivore abundance, this increase in abundance did not consistently translate into higher visitation rates at individual fruiting trees, which provides some support for the resource dilution hypothesis. Our results highlight the importance of considering fruit resource availability and frugivore abundance when examining variation in tropical plant-frugivore interactions.

Female-female competition is increasingly recognized as a key driver of female ornamentation, including birdsong, which often functions in intrasexual competition. However, the specific resources females use elaborate traits to compete for remain unclear. In addition, few studies have simultaneously investigated the use of multiple competitive traits in females, despite growing independent interest in these traits (e.g., female song and aggression). We investigated the competitive contexts of female song, aggression and calling behavior in northern house wrens (Troglodytes aedon) to determine which resources females compete for across the breeding season. We simulated conspecific territorial intrusions using female song at three breeding stages representing different contexts: arrival (mate and territory acquisition), nest building (nest site and breeding status defense), and egg laying (brood defense). We tested whether female song and physical aggression varied as reproductive resources shifted across the breeding cycle. Females were significantly more aggressive during nest building, showing 5.8 times greater odds of a higher-intensity aggressive response during nest building compared to arrival. Female song output was similar across early stages but declined during egg laying, though this was not statistically significant after correction for multiple comparisons and individuals varied substantially in overall singing propensity. Non-song vocalizations varied by call type and breeding stage. Calls associated with aggression occurred most frequently during nest building, consistent with peak physical aggression responses. Together, these results identify nest building as the stage of highest female aggression, consistent with heightened competition over nest cavities and associated breeding status in this cavity-nesting species. In contrast, female song occurred across all stages and appears to function in multiple competitive contexts. This study provides evidence for context and mode-specific female signaling in a temperate songbird and highlights that females strategically use aggression, calls, and song to mediate social conflict across breeding contexts.

In Baltic grey seals (Halichoerus grypus), interannual variation in sea-ice availability can alter the proportion of females breeding on land, generating substantial variation in local breeding density among years. We investigated preweaning survival, post-weaning residence, and weaning body condition at a Baltic grey seal land-breeding colony over two years with contrasting colony densities. Drone imagery provided repeated counts of pups in distinct developmental stages and estimates of moulting pup mass as an index of weaning body condition. A Bayesian state-space population model estimated substantially greater pup production in the high- (282.5 [95% CrI = 252.8 to 320.9] pups) than the low-density (188.3 [95% CrI =168.9 to 210.8] pups) year, but similar preweaning survival (0.66 [95% CrI = 0.53 to 0.81] and 0.67 [95% CrI = 0.56 to 0.79], respectively). In contrast, post-weaning residence differed substantially between the high- (11.8 [95% CrI = 9.2 to 15.7] days) and low-density (30.3 [95% CrI = 23.1 to 39.1] days) years. Greater exposure to other pups during early life was associated with lower weaning body mass ({beta} = -0.45 [-0.89 to -0.01], P[{beta} < 0] = 0.98). Together, these results suggest that the consequences of higher breeding density may emerge through poorer weaning condition and altered post-weaning residence even when effects on preweaning survival are not detectable.

Understanding when species diversification and phenotypic evolution are coupled remains a central challenge in macroevolution. Such coupling may depend on the traits considered, phenotypic integration, or the geographic context in which diversification occurs. Here, we investigate these relationships in Ithomiini, a diverse Neotropical butterfly tribe whose diversification is strongly associated with the Andes-Amazonia system. We quantified forewing and hindwing size and shape for 1,618 individuals representing 291 species using geometric morphometrics, and combined these data with phylogenetic comparative methods, diversification-rate estimates, and spatial analyses of species distributions. Evolutionary rate shifts were largely trait- and wing-specific, indicating limited coupling between forewing and hindwing evolution. Across the phylogeny, wing size evolution and extant wing size were not associated with species diversification, nor was hindwing shape evolution. By contrast, forewing shape evolutionary rates showed a positive association with diversification. Spatial analyses revealed that this coupling was geographically concentrated in the Andes, where high diversification rates coincided with elevated forewing size and shape diversity and increased forewing evolutionary rates. Hindwing diversity, by contrast, more closely tracked phylogenetic diversity and showed weaker or opposing relationships with diversification. Our results show that diversification and phenotypic evolution in Ithomiini are neither generally coupled nor fully independent, but linked in trait-specific and geographically structured ways. More broadly, they highlight the need to decompose complex phenotypes and integrate spatial context when testing macroevolutionary coupling.

Fluctuating asymmetry (FA) is widely used as a proxy for developmental instability, although reduced rather than increased FA, has occasionally been reported under particularly challenging conditions, possibly because environmental filtering removes less developmentally stable individuals. Here, we investigated temporal variation in wing shape asymmetry in males of Drosophila sturtevanti collected in 2022, 2024, and 2026 at the same sampling site, an urban Atlantic Forest fragment. Sampling in 2022 and 2026 were completed during single field expeditions in early April, whereas in 2024 repeated collections were required until mid-May because of markedly low capture success. We therefore examined whether this difference was associated with unusual environmental conditions and whether FA was higher in 2024, as expected under greater developmental perturbation. Daily temperature and relative humidity were examined from early March onward, encompassing approximately one month before adult emergence. The 2024 sampling period was warmer and drier than the corresponding periods in 2022 and 2026 and coincided with the final phase of the strong 2023-2024 El Ni&ntildeo event. Contrary to our prediction, FA was significantly lower in 2024. The magnitude of directional asymmetry remained similar among years, although the spatial pattern of the DA vector differed between 2024 and 2026. The coincidence of reduced capture success and reduced FA is consistent with the hypothesis that adverse conditions may impose demographic filtering, such that individuals expressing greater developmental instability are less likely to contribute to the sampled adult population.